Practices for reflexive design: lessons from a Dutch programme on sustainable agriculture

摘要: Not coincidentally, deliberative policy analysis has been practiced often in cases that a very essential sense involve value dissent and major uncertainties: of what Beck, Giddens others have designated "reflexive modernisation". Deliberation, under such circumstances, is to support synthesising kind judgment across existing differentiations distinctions, process judgement which assumptions, knowledge claims, roles identities, normally taken for granted, must be critically scrutinised. Thus, institutions tend provide inadequate guidance design". In this paper, we shed some light on challenge by telling reviewing the story Programme 348: "Future Livestock Production Systems" reflexive modernisation Dutch agriculture, following crises country's husbandry sector. Although an institutional arrangement had created was rather favourable design, programme encountered significant difficulties, argue are rooted emerged throughout agricultural over past century. We then use Wenger's insights "communities practice", as framework both understand how established could manifest themselves P348's arrangement, these difficulties dealt with more or less successful ways. With thus gained, wish contribute still underdeveloped literature design trail recent work Forester Fischer.