A 'joint venture' model of recontacting in clinical genomics: challenges for responsible implementation

作者: Sandi Dheensa , Daniele Carrieri , Susan Kelly , Angus Clarke , Shane Doheny

DOI: 10.1016/J.EJMG.2017.05.001

关键词: DutyNormativeInformation and Communications TechnologyGenetic testingData sharingBiologyTransparency (behavior)Process (engineering)Medical educationCLARITY

摘要: Advances in genomics often lead healthcare professionals (HCPs) to learn new information, e.g., about reinterpreted variants that could have clinical significance for patients seen previously. A question arises of whether HCPs should recontact these former patients. We present some findings interrogating the views (or parents patients) with a rare or undiagnosed condition how such recontacting might be organised ethically and practically. Forty-one interviews were analysed thematically. Participants suggested 'joint venture' model which efforts are shared HCPs. Some proposed an ICT-approach involving electronic health record automatically alerts them potentially relevant updates. The need rigorous privacy controls transparency who access their data was emphasised. Importantly, highlight lack clarity is symptom wider problem: necessary infrastructure pool genomic responsibly, aggregate it other data, enable patients/parents receive hope our will instigate debate way responsibilities under any joint venture allocated, as well limitations normative implications using ICT solution this intractable problem. As first step delineating setting, we suggest routinely discuss patients/parents, including information trigger HCP initiate recontact, part consent process genetic testing.

参考文章(32)
Lori B. Andrews, Torts and the Double Helix: Malpractice Liability for Failure to Warn of Genetic Risks Houston law review / University of Houston. ,vol. 29, pp. 149- 184 ,(1992)
Béatrice Godard, Martin Letendre, Expanding the physician's duty of care: a duty to recontact? Medicine and law. ,vol. 23, pp. 531- ,(2004)
Karen L. Brown, Diana M. Moglia, Sherry Grumet, Genetic Counseling for Breast Cancer Risk: General Concepts, Challenging Themes and Future Directions Breast Disease. ,vol. 27, pp. 69- 96 ,(2007) , 10.3233/BD-2007-27105
Sarah E Ali-Khan, Abdallah S Daar, Cheryl Shuman, Peter N Ray, Stephen W Scherer, None, Whole genome scanning: resolving clinical diagnosis and management amidst complex data. Pediatric Research. ,vol. 66, pp. 357- 363 ,(2009) , 10.1203/PDR.0B013E3181B0CBD8
Neil F. Sharpe, The Duty to Recontact: Benefit and Harm American Journal of Human Genetics. ,vol. 65, pp. 1201- 1204 ,(1999) , 10.1086/302587
Mary Z. Pelias, Duty to disclose in medical genetics: A legal perspective American Journal of Medical Genetics. ,vol. 39, pp. 347- 354 ,(1991) , 10.1002/AJMG.1320390320
Mitzi L. Murray, Felecia Cerrato, Robin L. Bennett, Gail P. Jarvik, Follow-up of carriers of BRCA1 and BRCA2 variants of unknown significance: Variant reclassification and surgical decisions Genetics in Medicine. ,vol. 13, pp. 998- 1005 ,(2011) , 10.1097/GIM.0B013E318226FC15
Adrienne C Sexton, Sylvia A Metcalfe, Disclosing Genetic Research Results After Death of Pediatric Patients JAMA. ,vol. 300, pp. 1693- 1695 ,(2008) , 10.1001/JAMA.300.14.1693
A. C. Sexton, M. Sahhar, D. R. Thorburn, S. A. Metcalfe, Impact of a genetic diagnosis of a mitochondrial disorder 5-17 years after the death of an affected child. Journal of Genetic Counseling. ,vol. 17, pp. 261- 273 ,(2008) , 10.1007/S10897-007-9145-9