Genetically modified organisms and the age of (Un) reason? A critical examination of the rhetoric in the GMO public policy debates in Ghana

作者: Joseph Kangmennaang , Lydia Osei , Frederick A. Armah , Isaac Luginaah

DOI: 10.1016/J.FUTURES.2016.03.002

关键词: SociologyAdversarial systemLawRhetorical questionPolicy analysisGovernmentEntitlementPublic policyCivil societyRhetoricLaw and economics

摘要: Abstract Using narrative policy analysis we examined the adversarial rhetoric of claims-makers in their bid to undermine alternative and conflicting accounts GMOs as environmental human health risk forestall any challenges scientific authority technological deterministic account GMO debates Ghana. The study shows that discourse was built with rhetorical frames smallholder farmer vulnerability entitlement used it contradicts, thereby legitimating its own appeal for responsive remedies. Civil society claims attacked discriminatory an risk. Government scientists engaged unsympathetic counter strategies hopes debunking or neutralizing claim made by civil society. In other words, were denying posed significant risk, well call action do something about GMOs. adapted insincerity, claiming had some kind “hidden agenda” behind claim, such eagerness just earn money from patents on It is imperative communication includes underlying assumptions, uncertainties probabilities associated both best worst case scenarios. This a necessary condition minimise misinformation but may be insufficient completely erase conspiracy theories minds public especially when government are perceived biased towards multinational corporations ostensibly preoccupied making profits.

参考文章(37)
Joël Spiroux de Vendômois, Dominique Cellier, Christian Vélot, Emilie Clair, Robin Mesnage, Gilles-Eric Séralini, Debate on GMOs health risks after statistical findings in regulatory tests International Journal of Biological Sciences. ,vol. 6, pp. 590- 598 ,(2010) , 10.7150/IJBS.6.590
Vern R. Walker, The Myth of Science as a ‘Neutral Arbiter’ for Triggering Precautions Boston College international and comparative law review. ,vol. 26, pp. 197- ,(2003)
Austin Bradford Hill, THE ENVIRONMENT AND DISEASE: ASSOCIATION OR CAUSATION? Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine. ,vol. 58, pp. 295- 300 ,(1965) , 10.1177/0141076814562718
David Winickoff, Lawrence Busch, Brian Wynne, Robin Grove-White, Sheila Jasanoff, Adjudicating the GM Food Wars: Science, Risk, and Democracy in World Trade Law. Yale Journal of International Law. ,vol. 30, pp. 3- ,(2005)
Frederick A. Armah, Isaac Luginaah, Justice Odoi, Artisanal small-scale mining and mercury pollution in Ghana: a critical examination of a messy minerals and gold mining policy Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences. ,vol. 3, pp. 381- 390 ,(2013) , 10.1007/S13412-013-0147-7
Theodoros H. Varzakas, Ioannis S. Arvanitoyannis, Haralambos Baltas, The politics and science behind GMO acceptance. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition. ,vol. 47, pp. 335- 361 ,(2007) , 10.1080/10408390600762696