Bringing in the controversy: re-politicizing the de-politicized strategy of ethics committees

作者: Lonneke Poort , Tora Holmberg , Malin Ideland

DOI: 10.1186/2195-7819-9-11

关键词:

摘要: Human/animal relations are potentially controversial and biotechnologically produced animals animal-like creatures – bio-objects such as transgenics, clones, cybrids other hybrids have often created lively political debate since they challenge established social moral norms. Ethical issues regarding the human/animal in biotechnological developments at times been widely debated many European countries beyond. However, general trend is a move away from parliamentary public towards institutionalized ethics technified expert panels. We explore by using conceptual lens of bio-objectification what effects can be said to have. In process, unstable bio-object becomes stabilized receives single “bio-identity” closing debate. we argue that there possible routes processes take, allow for more open-ended cases. By comparing our observations analyses deliberations three different will how process works context animal committees. From this comparison found an interesting common feature: When biotechnology discussed committees, technical pragmatic matters foregrounded. noticed silence around striking consensus culture. The present paper, seeks understand so complexity through well discuss ethical involved could become re-politicized, thereby made pluralistic, “ethos controversies”.

参考文章(32)
Charles J. Leslie, Life in the 21st Century. USA Today. ,vol. 111, pp. 26- 30 ,(1982)
Lynda I. A. Birke, Arnold Arluke, Mike Michael, None, The Sacrifice: How Scientific Experiments Transform Animals and People ,(2006)
Sarah Franklin, Jane Maienschein, Dolly Mixtures: The Remaking of Genealogy ,(2007)
Jürgen Habermas, Thomas Burger, The structural transformation of the public sphere : an inquiry into a category of bourgeois society Published in <b>1989</b> in Cambridge by Polity press. ,(1989)
Malin Ideland, Tora Holmberg, Challenging bio-objectification : adding noise to transgenic silences Bio-objects : life in the 21st century. pp. 13- 26 ,(2012)
W. M. S. Russell, R. L. Burch, The principles of humane experimental technique ,(1992)