"Green Revolution and Redistribution of Rural Incomes: Pakistan's Experience" - A Comment

作者: M. Ghaffar Chaudhry

DOI: 10.30541/V21I3PP.173-205

关键词:

摘要: In view of the significance technological break-through and changing pattern income distribution in process economic development, I recently published an article [I, pp. 173-205] which dealt with redistributive impact Green Revolution technology on rural incomes Pakistan. Basingmy judgement available empirical evidence, argued that Pakistan was accompanied by improvement distribution. Of course, also implied there existed no room for opposite, but generally prevalent, inequalities had worsened growing dependence technologies. a comment my [3, 47-56] Professor Mahmood Hasan Khan (hereafter referred tq as M. H. sake brevity) has alleged most conclusions study are erroneous because (1) have concentrated evidence from few districts Punjab generalized it country, (2) been eclectic use (3) did not even elementary statistical methods to test representativeness averages arrived at study. Apart these general comments, he raised numerous small points questioning validity arguments each sections Since is ardent supporter currently prevalent viewsabout adverse effects inl -viewswhich were challenged negated me - he, perhaps his preoccupation own opinions, overlooked advanced me1 places distorted arguments. It therefore, professional duty reply *Dr. Chaudhry Chief Research (Economics) Institute Development

参考文章(32)
David Turnham, Ingelies Jaeger, The Employment problem in less developed countries: A review of evidence OECD Publications Center, Suite 1207, 1750 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20006 ($5.00). ,(1971)
Mcinerney, J. Donaldson, G. Deder, The consequences of farm tractors in Pakistan pp. 1- 100 ,(1975)
Gavan Butler, Montague Yudelman, Ranadev Banerji, Technological change in agriculture and employment in developing countries Development Centre of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. ,(1971)
S. M. Naseem, Underdevelopment, poverty and inequality in Pakistan Vanguard Publications. ,(1981)
Dilawar Ali Khan, Employment and occupational change in the rural Punjab : consequences of green revolution Punjab Economic Research Institute. ,(1978)
M. Ghaffar Chaudhry, Rural Income Distribution in Pakistan in the Green Revolution Perspective The Pakistan Development Review. ,vol. 12, pp. 247- 258 ,(1973) , 10.30541/V12I3PP.247-258
Moazam Mahmood, Adeem-Ul- Haque, Farm Size and Productivity Revisited The Pakistan Development Review. ,vol. 20, pp. 151- 190 ,(1981) , 10.30541/V20I2PP.151-190
Stephen Guisinger, Mohammad Irfan, Real Wages of Industrial Workers in Pakistan: 1954 to 1970 The Pakistan Development Review. ,vol. 13, pp. 363- 388 ,(1974) , 10.30541/V13I4PP.363-388
Ronald Herring, M. Ghaffar Chaudhry, The 1972 land reforms in Pakistan and their economic implications : a preliminary analysis The Pakistan Development Review. ,vol. 13, pp. 245- 279 ,(1974) , 10.30541/V13I3PP.245-279
Ghulam Mohammad, Private Tubewell Development and Cropping Patterns in West Pakistan The Pakistan Development Review. ,vol. 5, pp. 1- 53 ,(1965) , 10.30541/V5I1PP.1-53