Do Planners Get it Right? : The Accuracy of Travel Demand Forecasting in Norway

作者: James Odeck , Morten Welde

DOI:

关键词:

摘要: This paper deals with the accuracy of travel demand forecasts among Norwegian road projects. We use data collected from tolled roads and toll free roads. The results reveal that while traffic schemes are fairly accurate, have a higher degree inaccuracy generally underestimated. An explanation for observed discrepancy between estimated actual is planners may ignored existence induced standard national growth rates used in transport models has been too low. For roads, an forecast over years scrutinized to provide careful estimates. Our recommendation provided by should constantly be subjected scrutiny independent consultants before being presented decision makers. Aspects need specifically examined include: (1) extent which project lead traffic, (2) accommodate appropriate factors and, (3) made address uncertainties providing confidence intervals

参考文章(20)
R H Muller, EXAMINING TOLL ROAD FEASIBILITY STUDIES Public Works Financing. ,vol. 97, ,(1996)
A Kjerkreit, J Odeck, The accuracy of ex-ante benefit cost analysis – a post opening evaluation in the case of Norwegian road projects International Transport Economics Conference (ITrEC), 2009, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA. ,(2009)
Jan-Eric Nilsson, INVESTMENT DECISIONS IN A PUBLIC BUREAUCRACY: A CASE STUDY OF SWEDISH ROAD PLANNING PRACTICES Journal of Transport Economics and Policy. ,vol. 25, pp. 163- 175 ,(1991)
O Osland, A Strand, The Politics and Institutions of Project Approval - a Critical-Constructive Comment on the Theory of Strategic Misrepresentation European Journal of Transport and Infrastructure Research. ,vol. 10, ,(2010)
R Bain, L Polakovic, Traffic forecasting risk study update 2005: through ramp-up and beyond PROCEEDINGS OF ETC 2005, STRASBOURG, FRANCE 18-20 SEPTEMBER 2005 - TRANSPORT POLICY AND OPERATIONS - ROAD FINANCE DESIGN AND MAINTENANCE - TRAFFIC AND REVENUE FORECASTING. ,(2005)
J Plantagie, R Bain, Traffic forecasting risk: study update 2004 PROCEEDINGS OF THE EUROPEAN TRANSPORT CONFERENCE (ETC) 2004 HELD 4-6 OCTOBER 2004, STRASBOURG, FRANCE. ,(2004)
Phil Goodwin, Robert B. Noland, Building new roads really does create extra traffic: a response to Prakash et al. Applied Economics. ,vol. 35, pp. 1451- 1457 ,(2003) , 10.1080/0003684032000089872
Robert Bain, Error and optimism bias in toll road traffic forecasts Transportation. ,vol. 36, pp. 469- 482 ,(2009) , 10.1007/S11116-009-9199-7