Does uncontrolled cardiac death for organ donation raise ethical questions? An opinion survey.

作者: V. GOUDET , M. ALBOUY-LLATY , V. MIGEOT , B. PAIN , C. DAYHOT-FIZELIER

DOI: 10.1111/AAS.12179

关键词:

摘要: BACKGROUND: Organ donation after uncontrolled cardiac death raises complex ethical issues. We conducted a survey in large hospital staff population, including caregivers and administrators, to determine their viewpoints regarding organ death. METHODS: Multicenter observational using questionnaire, information on the practical modalities of procedure. Respondents were asked answer 15 detailed questions corresponding different issues raised literature. Ethical concerns was defined when respondents expressed answers at least three nine specifically selected questions. RESULTS: One thousand one hundred ninety-six questionnaires received, 1057 could be analysed. According our definition, 573 out (54%) had with regard 484 (46 %) no concerns. Physicians (55%) particularly junior intensivists (65%) tended have more than nurses (52%) managers (37%). Junior senior (59%), emergency room physicians (46%) transplant specialists (43%). CONCLUSION: Only 46% hospital-based appear accept easily legitimacy death. A significant number especially intensivists, over dilemma between interests individual those society. These results underline need better inform both healthcare professionals general population help development such procedure. 2013 The Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica Foundation.

参考文章(20)
Christopher James Doig, Graeme Rocker, None, Retrieving organs from non-heart-beating organ donors: a review of medical and ethical issues Canadian Journal of Anaesthesia-journal Canadien D Anesthesie. ,vol. 50, pp. 1069- 1076 ,(2003) , 10.1007/BF03018376
Mohamed Y Rady, Joseph L Verheijde, Joan McGregor, Organ donation after circulatory death: the forgotten donor? Critical Care. ,vol. 10, pp. 166- 166 ,(2006) , 10.1186/CC5038
Leslie Whetstine, Stephen Streat, Mike Darwin, David Crippen, Pro/con ethics debate: When is dead really dead? Critical Care. ,vol. 9, pp. 538- 542 ,(2005) , 10.1186/CC3894
Robert D. Truog, Consent for Organ Donation — Balancing Conflicting Ethical Obligations The New England Journal of Medicine. ,vol. 358, pp. 1209- 1211 ,(2008) , 10.1056/NEJMP0708194
Joseph L Verheijde, Mohamed Y Rady, Joan McGregor, Presumed consent for organ preservation in uncontrolled donation after cardiac death in the United States: a public policy with serious consequences. Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine. ,vol. 4, pp. 15- 15 ,(2009) , 10.1186/1747-5341-4-15
M Susan Mandell, Stacy Zamudio, Debbie Seem, Lin J. McGaw, Geri Wood, Patricia Liehr, Angela Ethier, Anthony M. D’Alessandro, National evaluation of healthcare provider attitudes toward organ donation after cardiac death* Critical Care Medicine. ,vol. 34, pp. 2952- 2958 ,(2006) , 10.1097/01.CCM.0000247718.27324.65
Alessandro Nanni Costa, J M. Simón i Castellvì, Antonio G. Spagnolo, Nunziata Comoretto, Jean Laffitte, Håkan Gäbel, Francis L. Delmonico, Ferdinand Muehlbacher, Walter Schaupp, Alexandra K. Glazier, Valter D. Garcia, Mario Abbud-Filho, Jose O. Medina-Pestana, Mariangela Gritta Grainer, Pier Paolo Donadio, Anna Guermani, Riccardo Bosco, Francesco Giordano, Blanca Martinez Lopez de Arroyabe, Marco Brunetti, Martí Manyalich, Gloria Páez, Ricardo Valero, Rafael Matesanz, Elisabeth Coll, Beatriz Dominguez-Gil, Beatriz Mahillo, Eduardo Martin Escobar, Gregorio Garrido, Felix Cantarovich, A colloquium on the congress "A gift for life. Considerations on organ donation". Transplantation. ,vol. 88, ,(2009) , 10.1097/TP.0B013E3181B66576
James M. DuBois, Michael DeVita, Donation after cardiac death in the United States: How to move forward* Critical Care Medicine. ,vol. 34, pp. 3045- 3047 ,(2006) , 10.1097/01.CCM.0000248525.53130.57
Richard S. Luskin, Alexandra K. Glazier, Francis L. Delmonico, Organ Donation and Dual Advocacy New England Journal of Medicine. ,vol. 358, pp. 1297- 1298 ,(2008) , 10.1056/NEJMC086039
K. Hornby, L. Hornby, S. D. Shemie, A systematic review of autoresuscitation after cardiac arrest Critical Care Medicine. ,vol. 38, pp. 1246- 1253 ,(2010) , 10.1097/CCM.0B013E3181D8CAAA