A comparison of three survey methods to obtain data for community mental health program planning

作者: Andrew Lee Hinkle , Glen D. King

DOI: 10.1007/BF00885530

关键词: Mental healthMedicineActuarial sciencePhoneFamily medicineComparabilitySurvey methodologySurvey samplingHealth psychologyPublic healthImmediate family

摘要: A perennial problem for mental health planners is assessing community needs and existing services. The three most common methods used to obtain this data are the telephone survey, mail-out questionnaire, face-to-face interview. However, there advantages disadvantages associated with each approach in terms of sampling, response rates, economic costs. present study utilized all survey same population order determine comparability obtained relative efficacy methods. standard 21-item questionnaire was developed demographic epidemiological data. This included nine Likert-type items opionions on a typical question such as "To what extent would you have confidence recommending Mental Health Center members your immediate family?" In first method, teams made door-to-door interviews complete 449 questionnaires random sample. second 1,000 were mailed sample returns requested. third 224 people randomly selected from directory asked respond over phone. Precautions taken ensure confidentiality responses. All respondents classified according two-factor index based occupation education. analyed whether comparable through divergent Results discussed implications given planners.

参考文章(13)
Orville R. Gursslin, Raymond G. Hunt, Jack L. Roach, Social Class and the Mental Health Movement Social Problems. ,vol. 7, pp. 210- 218 ,(1959) , 10.2307/799447
Stanley C. Plog, Explanations for a High Return Rate on a Mail Questionnaire Public Opinion Quarterly. ,vol. 27, pp. 297- 298 ,(1963) , 10.1086/267171
Stanley D. Imber, Earl H. Nash, Anthony R. Stone, Social class and duration of psychotherapy Journal of Clinical Psychology. ,vol. 11, pp. 281- 284 ,(1955) , 10.1002/1097-4679(195507)11:3<281::AID-JCLP2270110308>3.0.CO;2-U
Charles N. Weaver, Sandra L. Holmes, Norval D. Glenn, Some characteristics of inaccessible respondents in a telephone survey. Journal of Applied Psychology. ,vol. 60, pp. 260- 262 ,(1975) , 10.1037/H0076494
Jerome K. Myers, Max P. Pepper, Lee L. Bean, August de Belmont Hollingshead, A decade later;: A follow-up of Social class and mental illness ,(1968)
Frank Auld, Jerome K. Myers, Contributions to a theory for selecting psychotherapy patients Journal of Clinical Psychology. ,vol. 10, pp. 56- 60 ,(1954) , 10.1002/1097-4679(195401)10:1<56::AID-JCLP2270100112>3.0.CO;2-T
RAYMOND G. HUNT, Social class and mental illness: some implications for clinical theory and practice. American Journal of Psychiatry. ,vol. 116, pp. 1065- 1069 ,(1960) , 10.1176/AJP.116.12.1065
Jerome K. Myers, Leslie Schaffer, Social Stratification and Psychiatric Practice: A Study of an Out-Patient Clinic American Sociological Review. ,vol. 19, pp. 307- ,(1954) , 10.2307/2087762