"ENGLISH FOR THE CHILDREN": RHETORICAL TRANSCENDENCE AND LANGUAGE IDEOLOGY IN CALIFORNIA'S PROPOSITION 227

作者: Abigail Oesterling

DOI:

关键词: National identitySociologyPoliticsIdeologyLanguage ideologySocial scienceNarrativeBilingual educationRhetorical questionMedia studiesBallot

摘要: Proposition 227, or “English for the Children” was a California ballot initiative created with purpose of eliminating state’s bilingual education programs and replacing them English-only instruction. Although many observers construed law as simply one in series efforts to roll back immigrants’ language access rights, measure diverged from previous restrictive legislation its rhetorical embrace immigrants. Its author, Ron Unz, constructed his campaign around notion that government support preventing immigrant children learning English, thereby denying opportunities and, broader sense, undermining societal unity by fostering linguistic divisiveness. This approach proved effective; on June 2, 1998, voters approved 227 margin sixty thirty nine percent. By explaining historical political factors animating Children,” this thesis argues California’s debate not merely disagreement over teaching methodologies, but reflected deeper, longstanding ideological conflict between competing visions ‘national identity’ how fits into scheme. The study is descriptive well analytical. Via narration main events forces shaping ideology U.S., it will first

参考文章(51)
John J. Attinasi, English Only for California Children and the Aftermath of Proposition 227 Education 3-13. ,vol. 119, pp. 263- ,(1998)
Rachel F. Moran, Bilingual Education as a Status Conflict California Law Review. ,vol. 75, pp. 321- ,(1987) , 10.15779/Z38B44N
Robert Linquanti, Phil Esra, Amy Merickel, Miguel Socias, Thomas B. Parrish, Leslie Brock, Maria Perez, Cecilia Speroni, Danielle Delancey, Angeline Spain, Effects of the Implementation of Proposition 227 on the Education of English Learners, K-12: Findings from a Five-Year Evaluation. Final Report for AB 56 and AB 1116. American Institutes for Research. ,(2006)
Charles Taylor, None, Multiculturalism: Examining the Politics of Recognition. Princeton University Press, 41 William St., Princeton, NJ 08540.. ,(1994)
Ron Unz, Immigration or the Welfare State Policy Review. pp. 33- ,(1994)
Laurie Olsen, The Role of Advocacy in Shaping Immigrant Education: A California Case Study. Teachers College Record. ,vol. 111, pp. 817- 850 ,(2009)
Francesco Cordasco, The Bilingual Education Act. Phi Delta Kappan. ,(1969)
James W. Tollefson, Mai Yamagami, Representation and Legitimization in Political Discourse: The Campaign against Bilingual Education 語学研究 = ICU Language research bulletin. ,vol. 25, pp. 1- 12 ,(2010)