A Methodological Critique of the 'Ideal Weight' Concept
作者： Thomas R. Knapp
DOI: 10.1001/JAMA.1983.03340040046030
关键词: Body height 、 Ideal weight 、 Sex factors 、 Ideal (set theory) 、 Body weight 、 Gerontology 、 Framingham Risk Score 、 Medicine 、 Positive economics 、 Body size
摘要: This article raises several objections to the procedures that were employed determine ideal (optimal, desirable) weights in 1959 and 1979 Build Blood Pressure studies, Framingham (Mass) study, recent study of relationship between weight mortality carried out by American Cancer Society. The new height-weight tables based on are also criticized. concludes with recommendation concept be abandoned attention devoted morbidity experience "outliers" (the very thin obese). ( JAMA 1983;250:506-510)
sci-hub.se 参考文章(22)
Andres R, Effect of obesity on total mortality. International Journal of Obesity. ,vol. 4, pp. 381- 386 ,(1980)
George A. Bray, Obesity in America ,(2018)
George A. Bray, The obese patient ,(1976)
CARL C. SELTZER, HOWARD W. STOUDT, BENJAMIN BELL, JEAN MAYER, Reliability of relative body weight as a criterion of obesity. American Journal of Epidemiology. ,vol. 92, pp. 339- 350 ,(1970) , 10.1093/OXFORDJOURNALS.AJE.A121216
Paul Sorlie, Body Build and Mortality JAMA. ,vol. 243, pp. 1828- 1831 ,(1980) , 10.1001/JAMA.1980.03300440030021
Edward A. Lew, Lawrence Garfinkel, Variations in mortality by weight among 750,000 men and women. Journal of Chronic Diseases. ,vol. 32, pp. 563- 576 ,(1979) , 10.1016/0021-9681(79)90119-X
Ancel Keys, Flaminio Fidanza, Martti J. Karvonen, Noboru Kimura, Henry L. Taylor, Indices of relative weight and obesity Journal of Chronic Diseases. ,vol. 25, pp. 329- 343 ,(1972) , 10.1016/0021-9681(72)90027-6
G. Terence Wilson, Methodological considerations in treatment outcome research on obesity Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. ,vol. 46, pp. 687- 702 ,(1978) , 10.1037//0022-006X.46.4.687
Robert J. Garrison, Cigarette Smoking as a Confounder of the Relationship Between Relative Weight and Long-term Mortality JAMA. ,vol. 249, pp. 2199- 2203 ,(1983) , 10.1001/JAMA.1983.03330400045023
Alan R. Dyer, Jeremiah Stamler, David M. Berkson, Howard A. Lindberg, Relationship of relative weight and body mass index to 14-year mortality in the Chicago Peoples Gas Company study Journal of Chronic Diseases. ,vol. 28, pp. 109- 123 ,(1975) , 10.1016/0021-9681(75)90067-3