Rebuttal comments on “Mitigating grain growth in binary nanocrystalline alloys through solute selection based on thermodynamic stability maps”

摘要: Abstract Darling et al. (2014) outlined a new model for nanocrystalline stability and applied it to large number of systems demonstrate its utility/applicability how visualize/select promising solutes in these systems. The present article addresses some the concerns raised by Lejcek Hofmann (2015) those that additional readers may have about this work. In cases we found their reflect ones are shared community developing applying sorts models. For instance, utilizing thermodynamic properties from such database systems, researchers should use due diligence extrapolating results real – be used as guide selecting prospective binary exhibit degree materials. Last, there was an oversight terms phase transformation temperature Fe Ti, which negligibly changed results. short, is intended bring light clarify items Hofmann.