Correlation between trainee candidate selection criteria and subsequent performance

作者: Jesse C. Selber , Winnie Tong , John Koshy , Amir Ibrahim , Jun Liu

DOI: 10.1016/J.JAMCOLLSURG.2014.07.942

关键词: Predictive powerMedical educationRaw scoreSocial skillsSpearman's rank correlation coefficientRanking (information retrieval)SurgeryTeamworkMedicineRank (computer programming)Personality

摘要: Background The objective of trainee recruitment is to identify candidates likely perform well as trainees and subsequent faculty. effectiveness this process has not been established. goal study was selection criteria predictive excellent performance. Study Design Twenty-nine microsurgery fellows were enrolled from 2008 2012. Each candidate interviewed rated based on presentation, plastic surgery (PS) training experience, academic potential, personality, social skills, communication ability be a team player. An unadjusted rank list generated weighted averages, an adjusted then at faculty meeting. At the conclusion fellowship, each fellow ACGME core competencies. Spearman correlation coefficients (r) used measure correlations between Results Plastic potential had, by far, strongest overall performance (r: 0.678, p Conclusions experience better predictors than any subjective information ascertained during interview. Adjustments discussion resulted in lower moving up ranking. Ranking interview techniques must refined improve power. It may beneficial for semi-objective carry more weight raw scores remain extraneous information.

参考文章(19)
Vijay K. Maker, Marco M. Zahedi, Dana Villines, Ajay V. Maker, Can We Predict Which Residents Are Going to Pass/Fail the Oral Boards? Journal of Surgical Education. ,vol. 69, pp. 705- 713 ,(2012) , 10.1016/J.JSURG.2012.08.009
Saroja Adusumilli, Richard H. Cohan, Kelley W. Marshall, James T. Fitzgerald, Mary S. Oh, Barry H. Gross, James H. Ellis, How well does applicant rank order predict subsequent performance during radiology residency Academic Radiology. ,vol. 7, pp. 635- 640 ,(2000) , 10.1016/S1076-6332(00)80580-2
Douglas R Dirschl, Edmund R Campion, Karen Gilliam, Resident selection and predictors of performance: can we be evidence based? Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research. ,vol. 449, pp. 44- 49 ,(2006) , 10.1097/01.BLO.0000224036.46721.D6
Mark M. Melendez, Xiaoti Xu, Thomas R. Sexton, Marc J. Shapiro, Eugene P. Mohan, The Importance of Basic Science and Clinical Research as a Selection Criterion for General Surgery Residency Programs Journal of Surgical Education. ,vol. 65, pp. 151- 154 ,(2008) , 10.1016/J.JSURG.2007.08.009
Daniel T. Farkas, Kamal Nagpal, Ernesto Curras, Ajay K. Shah, John Morgan Cosgrove, The Use of a Surgery-Specific Written Examination in the Selection Process of Surgical Residents Journal of Surgical Education. ,vol. 69, pp. 807- 812 ,(2012) , 10.1016/J.JSURG.2012.05.011
Tedric D. Boyse, Stephanie K. Patterson, Richard H. Cohan, Melvyn Korobkin, James T. Fitzgerald, Mary S. Oh, Barry H. Gross, Douglas J. Quint, Does medical school performance predict radiology resident performance Academic Radiology. ,vol. 9, pp. 437- 445 ,(2002) , 10.1016/S1076-6332(03)80189-7
Shaun G. Grewal, Lawrence S. Yeung, Steven B. Brandes, Predictors of Success in a Urology Residency Program Journal of Surgical Education. ,vol. 70, pp. 138- 143 ,(2013) , 10.1016/J.JSURG.2012.06.015
Richard B. Gunderman, Valerie P. Jackson, Are NBME examination scores useful in selecting radiology residency candidates Academic Radiology. ,vol. 7, pp. 603- 606 ,(2000) , 10.1016/S1076-6332(00)80575-9